Top 5 Vegan Mince Pies | Viva! - The Vegan Charity
Top 5 Vegan Mince Pies

Which high street vegan mince pie reigns superior?

It wouldn’t be Christmas without a mince pie or two – and now that most supermarkets sell vegan versions, there is no hope of not overindulging in these festive treats.

With so many options on where to buy from, it can be hard to know which one to go for. But don’t worry, here at Viva! we’ve been working hard trying all the biggest high street chain’s mince pies…all in the name of research of course!

So without further ado, here are our top 5 high street vegan mince pies…

5. Co-op

Price: £1 for 4 pies

Pastry: 2/5

Filling: 2/5

Aesthetics: 1/5

Value: 5/5

Total: 10/20

While they’re great value for money, these mince pies definitely leave a lot to be desired. The pastry is too crumbly and sticks to the roof of your mouth, and the ratio of pastry to filling is way off. In their defence, they are the co-ops freshly baked mice pies meaning its not only ‘free from’ shoppers who will be eating vegan, but don’t have your expectations very high.

4. Lidl

Price: £1.79 for 4

Pastry: 3/5

Filling: 3/5

Aesthetics: 3/5

Value: 2/5

Total: 11/20

These ones are gluten-free as well as vegan so maybe they should get double points for that! These mince pies are your average mince pies. The pastry is the right amount of crumbly and the filling is how you expect a mince pie to be. In conclusion, they’re not standout but no complaints either!

3. Sainsbury’s

Price: £1.50 for 4 pies

Pastry: 4/5

Filling: 3/5

Aesthetics: 3/5

Value: 3/5

Total: 13/20

Sainsbury’s Free From mince pies weigh in third, thanks to its near-perfect pastry and tasty filling. They look as good as they taste, the only thing we wish is there was more filling to balance out the ratios a little better. They’re available in the Free From section, meaning they might only be available in bigger stores…but we can live with that!

2. Café Nero

Price: £2 for 1 pie

Pastry: 4/5

Filling: 4/5

Aesthetics: 5/5

Value: 1/5


Arguably the most delicious of all the mince pies we tried, the price is what really split opinions here. Are they delicious? Definitely. Is the pastry crumbly? Of course. How is the filling to pastry ratio? Spot on! But are they worth £2 each? Not everyone is convinced… They are the best mince pie we tried but it’s really got to be something special to justify that price tag – but we all deserve a treat now and then don’t we?!

1. Greggs

Price: £1.75 for 6 pies

Pastry: 4/5

Filling: 3/5

Aesthetics: 4/5

Value: 4/5

Total: 15/20

Wow…Greggs have really outdone themselves with their vegan mince pies! The sweet filling is at a perfect ratio to the delicious pastry, and they even have icing sugar on top to take them the extra mile. They’re super cheap and since Greggs are everywhere it’s great to have somewhere we can easily pop into if those mince pie cravings sneak up on us.

If you're planning to have a homemade vegan Christmas this year, our Deliciously Vegan Christmas Guide has everything you need to make the festive season a roaring success. Buy it here!

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Going Vegan - How the Love of One Animal Brought Respect for all Life

Going Vegan - How the Love of One Animal Brought Respect for all Life

Guest Blogger |30/07/2020
In his final days my rabbit Tobbar chose to sit on the earth outside his warm comfortable shed. It was where he belonged. I felt like I was losing a friend, someone who’d helped me through the biggest upheavals of my life, including the deaths of my father and mother...
Ricky Gervais Backs Viva!’s Open letter to Boris Johnson

Ricky Gervais Backs Viva!’s Open letter to Boris Johnson

Guest Blogger |28/07/2020
Animal advocate, comedian and actor Ricky Gervais has joined dozens of other celebrities and experts by adding his voice to our campaign to end factory farming.
Snared by Bob Berzins

Snared by Bob Berzins

Lex Rigby |22/07/2020
Set against the beautiful backdrop of England’s moorland, Snared, exposes the pressures of rural life and tackles the brutal reality of countryside crime...
Literature and Activism

Literature and Activism

Will Sorflaten |22/07/2020
Using literature to make a difference.
How a Vegan Diet Can Improve Cognitive Health

How a Vegan Diet Can Improve Cognitive Health

Guest Blogger |17/07/2020
Following a vegan diet can help improve cognitive health!
Plastic-free July at Viva!

Plastic-free July at Viva!

Dani lawton |14/07/2020
Browse our best plastic-free buys...
Viva! Shop Summer Sale Favourites

Viva! Shop Summer Sale Favourites

Dani lawton |13/07/2020
The summer sale is in full swing on the Viva! Shop, with reductions across all of our categories! If you haven’t already had a gander, we recommend having a look now before your favourites get snapped up! Here’s a roundup of our “don’t miss” list:...