Why Some Dairy Products Are More Closely Linked to Parkinson’s Disease | Viva! - The Vegan Charity
Why Some Dairy Products Are More Closely Linked to Parkinson’s Disease

Parkinson’s is the second most common neurodegenerative disease after Alzheimer’s. Each year in the United States, approximately 60,000 new cases are diagnosed, bringing the total number of current cases up to about a million, with tens of thousands of people dying from the disease every year.

 

Is milk the scariest dairy product?

The dietary component most often implicated is milk, as I discuss in my video Could Lactose Explain the Milk and Parkinson’s Disease Link?, and contamination of milk by neurotoxins has been considered the “only possible explanation.” High levels of organochlorine pesticide residues have been found in milk, as well as in the most affected areas in the brains of Parkinson’s victims on autopsy. Pesticides in milk have been found around the world, so perhaps the dairy industry should require toxin screenings of milk. In fact, inexpensive, sensitive, portable tests are now available with no false positives and no false negatives, providing rapid detection of highly toxic pesticides in milk. Now, we just have to convince the dairy industry to actually do it.

Others are not as convinced of the pesticide link. “Despite clear-cut associations between milk intake and PD [Parkinson’s disease] incidence, there is no rational explanation for milk being a risk factor for PD.” If it were the pesticides present in milk that could accumulate in the brain, we would assume that the pesticides would build up in the fat. However, the link between skimmed milk and Parkinson’s is just as strong. So, researchers have suggested reverse causation: The milk didn’t cause Parkinson’s; the Parkinson’s caused the milk. Parkinson’s makes some people depressed, they reasoned, and depressed people may drink more milk. As such, they suggested we shouldn’t limit dairy intake for people with Parkinson’s, especially because they are so susceptible to hip fractures. But we now know that milk doesn’t appear to protect against hip fractures after all and may actually increase the risk of both bone fractures and death. (For more on this, see my video Is Milk Good for Our Bones?.) Ironically, this may offer a clue as to what’s going on in Parkinson’s, but first, let’s look at this reverse causation argument: Did milk lead to Parkinson’s, or did Parkinson’s lead to milk?

Milk and cheese increase risk

What are needed are prospective cohort studies in which milk consumption is measured first and people are followed over time, and such studies still found a significant increase in risk associated with dairy intake. The risk increased by 17 percent for every small glass of milk a day and 13 percent for every daily half slice of cheese. Again, the standard explanation is that the risk is from all the pesticides and other neurotoxins in dairy, but that doesn’t explain why there’s more risk attached to some dairy products than others. Pesticide residues are found in all dairy products, so why should milk be associated with Parkinson’s more than cheese is? Besides the pesticides themselves, there are other neurotoxic contaminants in milk, like tetrahydroisoquinolines, found in the brains of people with Parkinson’s disease, but there are higher levels of these in cheese than in milk, though people may drink more milk than eat cheese.

The relationship between dairy and Huntington’s disease appears similar. Huntington’s is a horrible degenerative brain disease that runs in families and whose early onset may be doubled by dairy consumption, but again, this may be more milk consumption than cheese consumption, which brings us back to the clue in the more-milk-more-mortality study.

Anytime we hear disease risks associated with more milk than cheese—more oxidative stress and inflammation—we should think galactose, the milk sugar rather than the milk fat, protein, or pesticides. That’s why we think milk drinkers specifically appeared to have a higher risk of bone fractures and death, which may explain the neurodegeneration findings, too. Not only do rare individuals with an inability to detoxify the galactose found in milk suffer damage to their bones, but they also exhibit damage to their brains.


About the Author

This is a guest blog written by Dr Michael Greger.  Michael Greger M.D. FACLM, is the Honorary Scientific Advisor of Viva!. He is a physician, New York Times bestselling author, and internationally recognised professional speaker on a number of important public health issues. Dr Greger has lectured at the Conference on World Affairs, the National Institutes of Health, and the International Bird Flu Summit, testified before the US Congress, appeared on The Dr Oz Show and The Colbert Report, and was invited as an expert witness in defense of Oprah Winfrey at the infamous "meat defamation" trial. Michael founded and runs the website, nutritionfacts.org.

 

You can find out more about dairy's link with chronic illness and how a vegan diet can help at vivahealth.org.uk.

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Creating & Sustaining Vegan Habits

Creating & Sustaining Vegan Habits

Nicholas Hallows |09/09/2019
Vegans often ask themselves, with so many reasons to adopt a plant-based diet – animals, environment, health – why aren’t more people doing it? One reason is that good habits are hard to form and bad habits are even harder to break...
September 2019: Viva! Vegan Podcast
In this episode, we celebrate Tesco dropping Hogwood Horror Farm after our three years of campaigning and the launch of our Hogwood crowdfunder ! Juliet and Lex Rigby talk about their experience of the Hogwood investigations. We talk about Viva! news and debunk vegan health myths.
The Question of Choice

The Question of Choice

Nicholas Hallows |03/09/2019
Anyone who has ever participated in vegan outreach will already have experienced a great number of ill-reasoned retorts to the suggestion of adopting an animal-friendly lifestyle: It’s too expensive! I need my protein! Soya is destroying the rainforests! Plants have feelings too!...
Top 5 Must-Have Recipe Books for New Vegans

Top 5 Must-Have Recipe Books for New Vegans

Guest Blogger |02/09/2019
There has never been a better, more exciting time to go vegan! If that’s something you’ve decided to do, arming yourself with one or more of these excellent vegan recipe books is a great way to start...
What the Labour Party Animal Welfare Manifesto Means for Animal Rights

What the Labour Party Animal Welfare Manifesto Means for Animal Rights

Louisa Kendal |30/08/2019
The Labour Party recognises the rights of all animals in their new manifesto which calls for equal punishment for all animal cruelty and supports a move away from intensive animal farming.
Juliet Debates Veganism on BBC Sunday Morning Live!

Juliet Debates Veganism on BBC Sunday Morning Live!

Guest Blogger |28/08/2019
Juliet explains why veganism is better for the animals, the planet and our health in a live BBC panel discussion, joined by Dale Vince and Tim Shieff.