|
Viva!
8 York Court Wilder Street Bristol BS2 8QH
Tel: 0117 944 1000
Fax: 0117 924 4646
email:
media@viva.org.uk
|
14 February 2001
ASA Slams Meat Industry
for False Animal Welfare Claims
Three out of four of the Meat & Livestock Commission’s
infamous pig advertisements have been judged misleading by
the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA). It follows a
complaint by Viva! over 10 months ago against the massive
campaign, costing £4.6 million and part-funded by
Government. Almost every daily newspaper in the country
carried the ads, urging consumers to buy British pork with
the slogan ‘Look after the farmers who look after their
pigs’.
Viva! complained that both pictures and copy presented a
misleading picture of pig production in Britain’s pig farms.
The ASA upheld our complaint saying: “... the three challenged
advertisements misleadingly implied that pigs reared under
the scheme led a more free life than they did”. The MLC was
asked to withdraw them and to take greater care not to
mislead in future.
The ASA found that consumers reading the ads would be
unaware that most pigs were not kept outdoors, that most
pigs are intensively farmed and that, despite the ads’
claims of good living conditions, they could consider the
size of pig stalls to be ‘tiny’.
“Almost all meat pigs in Britain are factory farmed,” says
Tony Wardle, Viva!’s deputy director. “ The MLC boasts of
high welfare standards yet never shows the public the real
conditions in which these intelligent animals are forced to
exist. These ads are typical - legalised animal abuse
camouflaged and wrapped in meaningless quality assurance
schemes. We know because we have filmed in over 20 pig
farms and the conditions we have recorded are shocking.”
Over the past five years, the ASA has found against the MLC
on 13 points, most as a result of complaints by Viva! They
include false claims that beef was perfectly safe to eat,
that vegetarians are more at risk of iron deficiency anaemia
and that vitamin B12 can be obtained only from meat. “The
MLC seems to care little for the accuracy of its copy and
for the welfare of pigs. Factory farming should be
abolished not promoted with public money and deceptive
advertising campaigns,” concludes Tony Wardle.
Ends
For further information contact Tony Wardle or Juliet
Gellatley on 0117 944 1000
|